Transcripts

American Dreamer:
The Legacy of Henry A. Wallace in Agriculture and Progressive Politics

Frank Holdmeyer

THE LEGACY OF HENRY A. WALLACE

Frank Holdmeyer
Editor, Wallace's Farmer


I'll start by quoting from a speech Henry A. Wallace delivered in Des Moines in 1962 about the city of Des Moines. He began by saying, "Somehow I rather feel I'm here under false pretenses because my recollections of Des Moines goes back only about 69 years. Many of you remember Des Moines back in the 1880s."
Well, that's how I feel today - I'm here under somewhat false pretenses talking to you about Henry A. Wallace. First of all, I never met him so my "recollections" are only what I've read or heard. Many of you know a lot more about him than I do. Nevertheless, I do have some comments for discussion. Naturally, many of them revolve around the Wallaces Farmer magazine.

INFLUENCE ON THE MAGAZINE
Henry A. Wallace was the third generation of Wallaces to lead the editorial direction of Wallaces Farmer. His official tenure was 1921-1933 but his name was carried on the masthead "editor on leave of absence" until 1946 while he served in Washington.
Wallace began writing for Wallaces Farmer while a student at Iowa State College. He wrote many articles about corn, based on his own experiments and observations, such as "productiveness vs. prettiness in corn" in 1907 and a series in 1909 called "On the Trail of the Corn Belt Farmer."
In 1910, upon graduation from Iowa State College, he went to work for the magazine full time. By 1915 he worked out the first short-cut method of computing corn-hog ratios. Reader surveys indicated his articles on corn and hog markets were very popular.
He was a leading proponent of using genetics to produce optimum yield hybrids and campaigned against the popular corn "beauty contests" of the era. He began dismantling corn varieties into their constituent bloodlines in his basement in 1913 and continued to conduct field trials.
He became editor in 1921 when his father Henry C. became secretary of agriculture.

WALLACE AS AN INNOVATOR IN AGRICULTURE - HIS MAIN CONCERNS ABOUT AGRICULTURE
Just like his father and grandfather, Wallace believed in the importance of rural life in maintaining a civilized society. He wrote editorials encouraging rural social organizations.
He created the state corn husking championships in 1921 and the Master Farmer competition in 1926.
During 1924 Wallaces Farmer ran a series of articles providing basic information on taxes and services to readers such as "What Iowa Schools cost the State. This was a typical Wallace approach. Rather than advocating an editorial position without providing basic information or twisting the facts, the Wallaces would provide the information needed to evaluate the situation and then might advocate a position.
The Wallaces believed in the importance of promoting an educated public motivated to participate in democratic society. Participation is the key word here.

CHANGES IN FARMING RESULTING FROM WALLACE'S INNOVATIONS. INCLUDING CHANGES IN FARM FAMILIES' QUALITY OF LIFE
The front page of the November 25, 1921 issue of Wallaces Farmer carried an article written by Henry A. Wallace. The title was, "Reducing the 1922 corn acreage - more clover, less corn, more money, the Corn Belt's slogan for the year."
Average corn price in Iowa in 1921 was 41 cents per bushel, far below the cost of production. In the article Wallace spelled out the causes for the low prices. Then he went into great detail his plan for reducing corn acreage in 1922. He cited the success of cotton reduction campaigns in the south as proof of how the plan could work.
Wallace ended the story with "these objectives are worthwhile in the long run from the standpoint of the corn farmer, the livestock farmer, the city man, and last but not least, from the standpoint of our soil fertility. We have but three months now to organize a campaign. There is no time to lose. Let's go!"
In 1921 Iowa farmers had harvested 9.2 million acres of corn. In 1922 the acreage of corn harvested by Iowa farmers was down to 8.8 million acres and average price was 64 cents per bushel. Now, I'm sure there were a lot of factors involved. Plus, corn acreage was reduced nationally. Nevertheless, Wallace was on the right track.

Here's another example of Henry Wallace's influence on farm families. I'm quoting from a book on the three generations of Wallaces. The headline reads: "The leadership of Wallaces Farmer and Iowa Homestead has saved Iowa farmers over $10,000,000 in Taxes since 1925."
Wallaces Farmer started to call attention to the injustice of the Iowa property tax system in 1922. "The editor of Wallaces Farmer brought to light certain existing inequalities in the state tax structure. He discovered that farmers were paying 67% of all state taxes, although farm population comprised only 42% of the state population. He discovered the average person living in the country paid $7.90 per year to run state government whereas the average person in town paid only $2.40.
These facts, together with others, were turned over to farm organizations for use at a hearing before the State Executive Council. As a result of this hearing, the Executive Council adjusted the taxable valuation of both farm and city property resulting in an annual savings to Iowa farmers of over $2,400,000.

At one time the National Corn Husking Contests , which ran from 1922 to 1942, was one of America's great festivals. In fact, the modern day Farm Progress Show is patterned after those contests.
Henry Wallace originated the state-wide contest in Iowa in 1922. Wallaces Farmer promoted the first contest offering a $50 prize. Henry A. Wallace wrote in his magazine, "We hope to see the day when farm people will get as much enjoyment out of watching corn huskers competing for a record as the people of the cities now get out of watching track athletes in their efforts to do unusually well in running and jumping."
It wasn't long before the contests became national in scope.

Henry Wallace also started the Wallaces Farmer Master Farmer Awards program in 1926. It's purpose is to call attention to the high level of management these farmers demonstrate and to award them for unselfishly devoting part of their time to community leadership roles.
Wallace himself wrote this about the Master Farmers in 1929. "The interests and efforts of these Master Farmers and their wives extend beyond doing well for themselves, their farms and their own families. They have visions of better communities, better and more prosperous neighbors, well trained, hopeful sons and daughters with high aims and ideals.
"These Master Farmers have contributed time, thought and money to make these dreams come true through strong and helpful cooperatives and service organizations, through better schools and roads, and churches that meet and help solve the problems of life, and by living at peace and in harmony with their neighbors."
Of course, by calling attention to these people, Wallace and Wallaces Farmer offered inspiration to other Iowa farmers to follow in their footsteps. We continue the award program today and the award is considered prestigious.. Since 1926, 390 Iowans have been so honored. This is just another tribute to the legacy of Henry Wallace

AI lot will be mentioned today about Henry Wallace's impact on agriculture but since the World Food Prize ceremonies were held in Des Moines recently I thought it appropriate to point out an instance of how Henry A. Wallace influenced agriculture around the world in a story related to me recently by Dr. Norman Borlaug.
Indirectly, Henry Wallace was responsible for the establishment of the first Foreign Technical Agricultural Assistance program. In December of 1940, when he was vice president-elect he was sent by President Roosevelt to represent him at the installation of the incoming president of Mexico. Keep in mind this was only a little more than a year before the attack on Pearl harbor. Mexico had undergone agrarian reform after the Mexican revolution but per capita food production was on the decline. Mexican leaders, knowing Wallaces's reputation as the founder of Pioneer Hi-Bred Seed, etc. invited him to go to the old parts of central Mexico for two days. He was shown the impoverished fields of corn and the Mexicans made a request for assistance to train Mexican scientists to do research to increase the yield of corn, wheat and beans.
Wallace was tremendously interested. This was something close to his heart. But when he got back to Washington and assumed the vice presidency he realized there had never been any funding for foreign agriculture. It would require a bill going through Congress and with the war clouds on the horizon, he knew this would never fly. So, he called the Rockefeller foundation and talked them into expanding their interests and helping our neighbors in Mexico. Eventually in 1943 this cooperative Mexican govern ment/Rockefeller Foundation program was initiated. The spin off from that first program led to the so-called green revolution.

WALLACE'S ROLE IN DEVELOPMENT OF HYBRID SEED CORN TECHNOLOGY
It was Wallace's curiosity and his unwillingness to accept old established answers that led him to translate hybrid corn from theory into practical farmer needs. His first challenge to the accepted theories of corn breeding came when he was only 16. In those days Wallaces Farmer held a corn growing contest for boys. P.G. Holden, a corn expert from Iowa State Agricultural College, judged the different ears and selected the winners. From the winning corn, he chose the thirty-three best ears and urged Henry A. Wallace to plant them the next spring.
Wallace did, an ear to a row. In the fall he husked the rows, weighed and carefully recorded the yield. Then the surprise. The most beautiful ear in the thirty-three was one of the poorest yielders.
The experiment greatly affected Wallace. From then on he had no respect for a merely beautiful ear of corn, the kind that won ribbons at corn shows. He believed, " a pig doesn't care how pretty the corn looks or how homely."
So, he set out to find a corn that would produce the best yield. The principle of crossbreeding and inbreeding had been developed as a botanical experiment. But it was Wallace who perfected in and made it adaptable to the Corn Belt. As early as December 1919 he urged upon the readers of Wallaces Farmer the possibilities of inbreeding and cross breeding.
He continued his testing and in the statewide Corn Yield Test of 1926 his hybrids walked away from the rest. They led in nine of the twelve districts with from three to ten more bushels per acre.
Naturally, Corn Belt farmers then wanted to know where to get the seed. Wallace was out in front once more. He organized a group of enthusiastic young college men who knew corn. They took over growing and crossing inbreds and distributing the resulting seed to farmers at a fair price.
Early in 1928 about 1,000 bushels of hybrid seed were placed on the market. "Through his own personal efforts, endless experiments and the influence of Wallaces Farmer, Wallace added over $1,300,000 to the farm wealth in Iowa in 1928." Quote from a brochure, "The man who made hybrids pay."

WALLACE'S VISION FOR AGRICULTURE AND HOW HE MIGHT RESPOND TO THE CURRENT SITUATION.
A few years ago senior management of the company that owns Wallaces Farmer decided to take the publication in a new direction. Where we had been broad-based and able to serve readers of all farm sizes, management wanted to attract and focus on the larger producers, in effect telling the average or small guy,"we don't need you anymore."
Not everyone agreed with this philosophy, myself included. I'm quite sure Henry Wallace would not have agreed either. This quote from the March 15, 1895 issue of Wallaces Farmer, the third paper under the total management of the Wallaces, is not directly from Henry A., but it is the Wallace philosophy with regard to their magazine. It reads: "Wallaces Farmer believes, that while one object in conducting newspapers is to make money, that is not the sole object. The man who has no higher aim in view in conducting a newspaper than to make money will go wrong as soon as his paper obtains power and influence and nothing can prevent it. It is not in human nature to resist temptation to make money illegitimately if there is no higher motive than the making of money. Its downfall is only a question of time."
Fortunately, our management has rethought the business strategy. In fact, we are considering partnering in a small farm conference in the near future. The staff and I feel that if Henry A. Wallace were the editor today he would jump at the opportunity.
Now that it has become abundantly clear that the largest percent of our readership are those folks who are farming smaller acreages and have offfarm jobs we are again going to try to serve those readers.
How would Wallace react to what's going on in agriculture today? First, I believe he would not be passive and remain silent. But we should keep in mind this point. The Wallace Editors had immeasurable freedom in writing and publishing their editorials. They owned the magazine. It's a different situation today. We can get into that more if you wish and if we have time.
In conclusion, I've asked my colleagues from time to time, what farm editor today would you compare to Henry A. Wallace? There is no one

 

 

Center for Prairie Studies

Home | Grinnell College Home Page

Last updated 19-Feb-2003