Composition and Analysis
Music 321: Advanced Musical Studies, Grinnell College, Winter/Spring, 2003

INSTRUCTOR, CONTACT INFORMATION, & OFFICE HOURS
 Jonathan Chenette,
Dept. of Music
chenet@grinnell.edu  x3065, BCA254

Ofc hours
Mon 10-11
Th 3-4


Required materials:

Powell, Steven. Music Engraving Today. New York: Brichtmark Music, 2002.
Torke, Michael. The Yellow Pages. New York: Boosey and Hawkes, 1985.
Takemitsu, Toru. Asterism. New York: C.F. Peters, 1969 (composed 1967).
Stiff music-writing paper, soft lead pencils, erasers.

Reference books:

Adler, Samuel. The Study of Orchestration. New York : Norton, 1982. Course reserve.
Read, Gardner. Music Notation; a Manual of Modern Practice. Boston: Crescendo, 1969. Course reserve.
Stone, Kurt. Music Notation in the Twentieth Century : A Practical Guidebook. New York: Norton, 1980.
Burling REF MT35 .S87Ê

Class description:

Composition and analysis of notated music in contemporary styles. Students will complete assigned composition and analysis projects, carry out their own composition projects based on music they are studying, develop computer and marketing skills relevant to professional work as a composer, and organize the presentation of at least one substantial composition in a public concert at the end of the semester. The course will consist of a mix of group meetings on topics of common interest, seminar critiques presenting and commenting on work in progress, and private lessons focused on individual projects in analysis and composition.
Grade breakdown:
Composition portfolio 45%
Writing projects: program notes, proposals, reviews 15%
Oral projects: analysis presentations, composer talks 15%
Analysis exam (The Yellow Pages and Asterism) 15%
Attendance, homework, preparation, & participation 10%

Policies and class structure:

Retain the original copy of every composition and bind it into a three-ring or other binder to keep as a portfolio of your work for the semester. Submit clear photocopies, using double-sided copying and some form of binding (tape, 3-ring, or spiral) for compositions exceeding three pages in length.
Students may request 2-day extensions on compositions by submitting a copy on the due date demonstrating considerable progress toward the work's completion and indicating in a type-written page what work remains to be done and why an extension is needed. No extensions will be granted for the mid-semester and final compositions, however.
On Wednesday, Apriln 30, the class will present a 7:30 p.m. concert of selected work produced during the semester. All students will participate in some aspect of the performance and presentation of this concert.

Questions to stimulate self-evaluation and discussion of compositions:

  1. Does the piece begin well? Does it have an interesting idea, well stated, that captures the listener's attention?
  2. Does the piece end well? Is there a sense of finality and completeness?
  3. If there are contrasting musical ideas, do they seem fresh and interesting and yet consistent with the original?
  4. Are elements of contrast sufficient for the length of the composition? Does the piece ever seem tedious and boring? Is it too long for its material?
  5. Are transitions compelling and effective? Do they ever seem forced and arbitrary?
  6. Are ideas developed adequately? Does the music ever seem to do too many new things too often? Is the length appropriate for the number of different musical ideas presented? Are ideas transformed inventively?
  7. Are the notes/rhythms correct? Do they fit together coherently?
  8. Is the music gratifyingly written for the instruments?
  9. Does the notation convey the musical intentions clearly and correctly?
  10. Does the piece have character? Is it memorable?
  11. Does the music fit the constraints of the assignment regarding length, character, vocabulary, technique, etc.?
  12. Would you want to hear this work again?

Date | Assignment Due

JANUARY

20 In-class introduction to course structure, projects, and goals.
22

Listen to tracks 1-14 of the study CD. Read Michael Torke's Composer Note for The Yellow Pages (1985).
Write a one- to two-page essay about your aspirations as a composer, your initial vision for your composer-organized ensemble composition, and how this vision relates to your background, previous compositions, and aspirations.

24

Continue marking up the score of The Yellow Pages (1985):
• identify any unfamiliar notations using sources such as the Virginia Tech Multimedia Music Dictionary, Gardner Read's Music Notation: a Manual of Modern Practice (RESERVE MT35.R253 M9 1969), Kurt Stone's Music Notation in the Twentieth Century (REFMT35 .S87), or The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians (REF ML100 .N48 2001).
• mark major points of change and indicate what elements change and stay the same at those points
• identify in detail the way the harmony, rhythm, motives, and texture develop from m. 39 to m. 90.

• How does the harmony develop from m. 5 to 38?
• How does the violin part develop between mm. 4 and 38?
• How do the flute and clarinet parts develop between mm. 7 and 38?

27 George Crumb Vox Balaenae (1971) and Joan Tower Petroushskates (1980). Listen, view the scores on reserve at Burling, and read the program notes, while beginning work on your composition for eighth blackbird.
29

Composition lessons:8 Nick Liebman 8:20 Richard West 8:40 Ari Hart 9 Ben Hanes 9:20 Pete Pennington 9:40 Jackie Puretz 11 Nick Malinowski

31 Sharing of work in progress: In approx. 5 minutes, present your progress on your composition to the other members of the class.Include a description of what you've accomplished so far, what main ideas you are exploring, how your music relates to other compositions we've listened to in class (if any), problems you're encountering, and things you're discovering along the way. You may ask me to read something through on the piano, if you wish.

FEBRUARY

3 John Harbison Variations (1982). Listen, study the score, and read the program note.
5 Compose; continue studying Torke score.

7

Composition lessons:8 Nick Liebman 8:30 Ben Hanes 9 Richard West 9:30 Pete Pennington 10:00 Jackie Puretz 11 Nick Malinowski 11:30 Ari Hart
10 eighth blackbird composition due: 3- to 5-minute composition for flute, Bb clarinet, violin, cello, and piano or at least three of those instruments. Style should be inspired, in some way, by the works we have been listening to and studying or by musical styles you began to explore in Intro to Composition class.
12

Five- to ten-minute composer presentations (verbal program notes) on eighth blackbird compositions: Ben Hanes, Ari Hart, Nick Liebman, Nick Malinowski. Listen to the spoken intro to Fast Track given by Jon Chenette at a concert in 2000 for an example of what you might cover; or go to the Fast Track Web page to see the artwork while listening to the spoken intro.

14 Five- to ten-minute composer presentations (verbal program notes) on eighth blackbird compositions: Pete Pennington, Jackie Puretz, Richard West.
Performance parts and written program notes for eighth blackbird compositions due.
Read the concert review "Good Things for the Few," written by Jon Chenette.
14
7:30 PM
S-L Hall
Concert: eighth blackbird
15 (Sat.)
10 AM
S-L Hall
Workshop: eighth blackbird
17 Concert review due: eighth blackbird.
19 Proposal for composer-organized ensemble compositios due, modeled on Iowa Arts Council Artist Project Grant. Composer presentations today by John Rommereim and Jon Chenette.
21 Composition lessons: initial drafts and ideas for composer-organized ensemble compositions
8:15 Pete Pennington 8:30 Richard West 8:45 Ari Hart 9 Ben Hanes 9:15 Nick Liebman 9:30 Nick Malinowski 9:45 Jackie Puretz

23 (Sun.)
2 PM
S-L Hall

Concert: "Music From Grinnell and Beyond," music for voices,strings, lute, and piano composed by John Rommereim, Jon Chenette, and Matt Cook.
24 Concert review due: "Music From Grinnell and Beyond."
26 Introduction to Continental Harmony.
28 Sharing of work in progress.

MARCH

3 Read Grinnell's call for a Continental Harmony composer in conjunction with Faulconer Gallery's "Roots of Renewal" programming for the fall of 2003 (or read the paper version handed out in class). Continue composing.
5 Presentation by Continental Harmony composer Craig Naylor. Revisions of Artist Project Grant proposals due today.
7 Composition lessons: 8 Richard West 8:30 Ben Hanes 9 Nick Liebman 9:30 Pete Pennington 10:00 Jackie Puretz 11Ari Hart 11:30 Nick Malinowski
10 Compose.
12 Edited CD's of eighth blackbird reading of composition 1 due. Refer to these instructions on using ProTools Free to edit the multiple takes into a single track suitable for CD burning.

In-class problem-solving composition session: bring in a problem spot in your composition -- a phrase that needs to be developed better, an unsatisfactory transition, a problem with counterpoint, harmony or notation, etc. -- and we'll work on solutions. Please print and bring in 8 copies of the problem page so we don't have to waste time with the computer or with writing the problem passage on the board.
14

Composer-organized ensemble composition due. Target duration 5-10 minutes. Compose for a soloist or ensemble of up to three musicians whom you have contacted in advance and who agree to work with you and perform your piece on the April 30 concert. The performers must be either Grinnell College Applied Music Associates from the approved list handed out in class or other musicians (advanced students or professionals) approved by the instructor before you contact them. Provided you submit a proposal that receives at least 80 points on the 120 point Iowa Arts Council Artist Project Grant scale, you will have available $150 for hiring AMA/professional musicians, with the money to be divided equally among the members of your ensemble; student performers will not be paid. You should use your performer(s) as a resource during the composition process:

  • invite them early on to inform you about the technical strengths and limitations of their instruments
  • have them suggest contemporary compositions for their instruments to serve as models for you to study
  • contact them when you have questions about notation or technique that can't be answered with the orchestration text on reserve or other resources
  • have them play through sketches and give you feedback, if they are willing

You will be responsible for setting up a rehearsal schedule for your ensemble for the month of April and being present to give feedback at rehearsals when the performers desire.

15-30

SPRING BREAK
31

Write me a letter covering these points and telling me anything else you would like to cover as part of a self-appraisal of your work and results on the most recent composition:

  • In working on the previous composition, how important were each of the following activities to your compositional process?:
    • coming up with the idea and a large-scale vision of the music
    • collaborating with your performers (discussing the capabilities of their instruments or voices, talking about model compositions for their instruments or voices, having them play through sketches and give feedback)
    • listening to and studying recordings and scores of model compositions
    • reading about notational practices and capabilities of your instruments in orchestration books, Music Engraving Today, etc.
    • composing o revising and editing
    • proofreading and improving notation
    • singing or playing through parts of your music to see how they sounded and felt
    • reading, reflecting, meditating, absorbing inspiration and influences
    • other composition-related activities (and what were they?)
  • Which of the above activities do you think warranted more or less attention than you devoted to them on the most recent composition, and why?
  • What were you happiest with about the most recent composition?
  • What would you most like to have improved about the most recent composition?
  • What would you like to focus on improving in the next composition?

APRIL

2 Complete any practicable revisions of your composer-organized ensemble composition, and create a professional quality score and parts, with page turns, piano pedal markings, slurs, spacing, page layout, graphic collisions, enharmonic spellings, courtesy accidentals, and all other notational issues carefully addressed. As appropriate for your composition, read the section in Music Engraving Today on Solo Voice (chapter 7), Keyboard (chapter 8), Orchestra (chapter 9, including information on part layout), or specialty notations (pp. 190-198.) [NOTE: Contrary to the book's recommendation, we will work with 8.5 x 11 page sizes because of ease of printing and photocopying.] Proof-read your score and parts carefully, copy them double-sided and in sufficient quantities for all your performers plus an extra copy of the score for you and me, and have them ready for binding and presenting to your performers as of Wednesday (we will bind them together in class.) You will receive a grade for the quality of these performance materials. You may invite a classmate or another student musician to view your materials and to give you feedback on things that need improvement.
4

Submit a proposal for a composition for soloist, small ensemble, or choir, minimum duration 6 minutes, based on the "Roots of Renewal" theme (see below) OR created for an ensemble whose director confirms to you his or her willingness to consider the music for performance OR conceived for a composer opportunity identified from among those published at sites such as the American Composers Forum's opportunities list or posted on the walls of the music seminar room. Any such opportunity should have a deadline after the composition due date of May 9. Your proposal should address the following:

  • The ensemble or opportunity for which you are composing the piece
  • What drew you to this particular project
  • Your initial vision of the piece, including its instrumentation, approximate duration, number of movements, general style, and inspiration
  • How you imagine this composition resembling or differing from other music you have composed thus far.
  • A bibliography of musical scores and recordings that you intend to study as you work on your music, with at least five different works that are related to your piece in some way (similar ensemble, similar vision, etc.) Explain how each is related, and give library call numbers or information on how you will obtain the material.
  • An approximate timeline for completion of phases of your work on this project between now and May 9.

To locate items for your bibliography, try a keyword search in the Burling catalog, entering the names of the instruments you are interested in separated by AND and setting the year to after 1950, etc. Read the instructions for word searching at the bottom of the page if you've never done so before. You'll discover, for instance, that you get different results by typing in "violin clarinet piano" than you do by typing "violin AND clarinet AND piano." Another source for scores to study is the SheetMusicPlus.com Web site, although these you will have to order and pay for yourself. CD's can often be located at the Amazon.com Web site.

Roots of Renewal theme: "New Immigrants, new industries, new farming practices, and new attitudes towards the original tall grass prairie are all changing the perception of the Upper Midwest in the early 21st Century. While still agriculturally grounded, virtually every aspect of the culture and land is being re-examined. Roots of Renewal.will use contemporary art as a catalyst for an exploration of the issues facing those who live in the region, as they rethink their land, their livelihoods, and their sense of self."

7 Submit rehearsal schedule for composer-organized ensemble composition.
Listen to and study Takemitsu Asterism (1967) page 1. Try to understand all the notations on the page, the types of pitch materials used, the rhythmic vocabulary, and how pitches receive emphasis and connect to each other.
Start work on composition 3.
9 Study Takemitsu Asterism, page 2.
11 Composition lessons: 8:30 Nick Liebman 8:45 Ari Hart 9:00 Ben Hanes 9:15 Richard West 9:30 Nick Malinowski 9:45 Pete Pennington
14 Study Takemitsu Asterism, pages 3-4.
16 Listen to all of Takemitsu's Asterism, focussing on the large-scale shape. Identify major points of change and the elements that contribute to your perception of formal articulations and relationships or contrasts between parts. Sketch the dramatic contour of the whole composition. Identify elements that give the ending a sense of resolution or completion.
18 Composition lessons: 8:30 Ben Hanes 9 Nick Liebman 9:30 Pete Pennington 11 Richard West 11:30 Nick Malinowski.
21 Study in detail the harmony and its unfolding in the last two pages of the score. Continued study of the formal articulation of Takemitsu's Asterism.
23 Written program notes for concert due.
25 Sharing of work in progress: problem-solving.
28 Composition lessons: 8:00 Nick Liebman 8:30 Pete Pennington 9 Ben Hanes 9:30 Ari Hart 11 Richard West 11:30 Nick Malinowski.

30

Continued discussion of Asterism, major points of change, possible topics for writing assignment.
30 7:30p.m. Class concert, Sebring-Lewis Hall and Herrick Chapel.
MAY

2

Write a paragraph beginning to develop a topic that you would like to focus on in your final exam project: a 4- to 6-page essay pertaining to Takemitsu's Asterism. Your essay will become part of a class Web site devoted to an analytical study of this work. Sample topics include:

  • The solo piano parts: how they develop, their timing, characteristic motives, visual elements, use of the asterism shape, and structural significance (Nick Malinowski)
  • The structure overall and how it prepares and recovers from the crescendo, with its possible depiction of a mental breakdown (Ari Hart)
  • The orchestra's call and response relationship with the solo piano (Ben Hanes)
  • Characteristic harmonic materials and pc-sets and their relationship to musical structure (Richard West)
  • Uses of the asterism shape on various levels of the musical structure
  • Measure 1's piano idea and its recurrences and importance as a source for other materials
  • The [0,2,5,7] pc-set, its manifestations as consecutive descending 4ths and as a melodic or harmonic element, its relationship to other harmonic and melodic materials, and its role in the musical structure
  • Other prominent pitch sets and their role in the music: WT, WT+1, octatonic
  • "Senza tempo" and "aleatoric counterpoint" sections as articulating elements in the musical structure
  • Chord voicings and voice leading practices and how they contribute to coherence in the music
  • Orchestration and its relationship to musical form
  • Focal pitches, how they are established, how they provide coherence between sections and contrasting materials, and what they reveal about the musical structure
5 Read chapter 6, "'Cage shock' and after," from Peter Burt's The Music of Toru Takemitsu, focusing especially on his discussion of Asterism on pp. 105-109. Analysis presentations: outline your ideas concerning the topic you will write about for the final exam essay, and lead a discussion designed to solicit feedback from your classmates.You will have half the class period available for a mix of presentation, analysis, and discussion. Today's presenters are Pete Pennington, Nick Malinowski.
7 Analysis presentations: outline your ideas concerning the topic you will write about for the final exam essay, and lead a discussion designed to solicit feedback from your classmates. You will have half the class period available for a mix of presentation, analysis, and discussion. Today's presenters are Ari Hart and Ben Hanes.
9 Final composition and program notes due: Prairie/Roots of Renewal or Composer Opportunity composition.
Analysis presentations: outline your ideas concerning the topic you will write about for the final exam essay, and lead a discussion designed to solicit feedback from your classmates. You will have half the class period available for a mix of presentation, analysis, and discussion. Today's presenters are Richard West and Nick Liebman.
14
(Wed)
noon
Final exam essay on Asterism due by noon; print the document, but also send me an email copy for posting on the Web. Choose a topic from the list above, or propose your own, and write a 4- to 6-page essay that develops an interesting thesis related to the topic and illuminates the structure, style, compositional technique, coherence, and/or emotional impact of Toru Takemitsu's Asterism. Incorporate musical examples or references to specific measures, pages, or traits of the score to support your ideas. Consider using a graphic or table to summarize your results while focussing in your text on a few of your most interesting discoveries. Your essay will become part of a class Web site devoted to Asterism and seeking to illuminate it to those who are musically literate and interested in Takemitsu's music but perhaps not familiar with this specific score.


last revised 5/22/07 by Jonathan Chenette