History 195.01
Spring, 1999
Prof. V. Brown
Ext. 3087
GRINNELL COLLEGE
Department of History

Cultural Encounters in History

This course examines seven "moments" in history when peoples with differing experiences, practices, values, and world views came into contact with one another. In a series of discrete units or "case studies," the course seeks to consider those factors in human society that cause such contact to occur and then shape the outcomes of such contact. For the purposes of this course, the term "culture" will refer quite broadly to that which humans create themselves in order to survive in and adapt to their environment, as well as the meanings humans attach to their daily experiences and cultural practices.

Without attempting anything so foolish as "global" history in one semester, this course does take us around the globe: to Latin America, to Africa, to Asia, to Europe, to North America. The purpose of this tour is to remind ourselves of the historical particularities as well as the human commonalities to be discovered in different cultural encounters. It is further our purpose to introduce students to the opportunities for intriguing historical study in all parts of the world.

In addition to moving around the globe, this course also moves through time. We begin in the 16th century and proceed into the late 20th century. This is a brief span of time relative to the wealth of human history that precedes the 16th century, but we hope it will convey the variety of stories and sources available to historians of the far and near past. We hope, as well, that it will create a sense of comfort with broad movement through time while also encouraging an appreciation for the value of close attention to chronology in any particular historical "moment."

This section of History 195 will meet every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday at 9:00 a.m. Success in the course — both for the individual and for the group — depends utterly on regular, reliable attendance. The pace at which we will be globe-trotting and the level of participation required for the endeavor render any individual's absence highly undesirable. The Class Contract you will be asked to sign makes clear the expectations for your participation in the class.

As an experimental course, History 195 demands much of its students. You have, whether you knew it at the time or not, signed on for a journey into uncharted waters and terra incognita. Like many of the explorers and migrants we are about to study, we embark on this journey well provisioned but without any actual experience of where we are headed. We can promise you great moments of discovery along with some long, dark nights. There will be no passive passengers on this trip. Be prepared to read, write, speak, and think a lot. If we all do that, this should be a pretty exciting maiden voyage.

Required Texts (all available at campus bookstore)
 

Leon-Portillo, Broken Spears
Thornton, Africa and Africans
Burns, France and the Dreyfus Affair
Mathanabe, Kaffir Boy
Malan, My Traitor's Heart

COURSE PACKET — available only at the campus bookstore

Writing Assignments

1.

Short assignments: These are from a half-page to a whole page, typed, double-spaced. They are listed on the syllabus as "Writing assignment" for the day on which each is due. The purpose of these assignments is to focus your reading and facilitate that day's discussion. It defeats this purpose to turn in a short writing after the relevant class is over. Please do not ask to do so.

There are twelve short writing assignments over the course of the semester. Each is worth a maximum of 10 points. Your overall score for those assignments will be calculated from a base of 100 points, meaning that you can skip two assignments or have one or two low scores dropped.

   
2. In-class exam: There will be one in-class exam this semester on Friday, October 1. You will know beforehand what you are going to be asked to write about on that exam. You will not use notes or books in the exam.
   
3. Research paper: You will have one opportunity this semester to research and write a short, 5-page paper using documents that will be made available to you in Burling Library. That paper will be due on Wednesday, November 24.
   
4. Take-home exam: Your final exam will be a take-home essay. You will have a choice of topics to write on. Those topics will be made available to you on December 10. The essay will be due on December 17.

Evaluation Policy

10 out of 12 short writings
1 in-class exam
1 research paper
1 take-home essay
Participation
Total points possible
= 100 points
= 50 points
= 100 points
= 100 points
= 150 points
= 500 points

I do not grade on a curve. Those who earn 90% or more of the points will receive an A or A-;
those who earn between 80% and 89% of the points will receive some sort of B grade; those who earn between 70% and 79% of the points will receive a C grade. I do not mention the grades D or F here because I do no expect anyone in this class to get in that situation. If I see you headed there, we will talk about how you can change direction.

The term "participation" is explained on the Class Contract. We will discuss further, in class, the various ways in which you can contribute to the learning community that you volunteered to join when you signed up for this class.


Victoria Brown's Office: Carnegie 406
(top floor, east side)

Victoria Brown's Office Hours --

  Mondays: 10:00 - noon, 2:30 - 4:00
Tuesdays: 2:00 - 4:00
Wednesdays: 10:00 - noon; 2:30 - 4:00
Fridays: 10:00 - noon

And by appointment.
   
Office Phone: ext 3087
Home Phone in Iowa City: 319-354-8867
E-mail: brownv@grinnell.edu

***Note that I live in Iowa City. This semester, I typically will be staying in Grinnell on Monday and Tuesday nights. You can reach me in my office during the day on Mondays, Tuesday afternoons, Wednesdays and Fridays. If you really need to reach me on Tuesday mornings, try: 236-3819. Same is true on Monday and Tuesday nights. If you need to reach me on Thursday or over the weekends and it cannot wait, do not depend on e-mail. Call me at home.

I will be the first to concede that the information superhighway does not stretch seamlessly between Grinnell and Iowa City. But you can always reach me somehow. I have phone answering machines at both my office and my home in Iowa City. I check e-mail quite regularly in Grinnell and from Iowa City. But during the week, I often cannot get to e-mail until the evening. If you need an answer during the day, that day, call me or stop by my office.

Be warned: I will growl unattractively if you utter these words: "I couldn't reach you." Thanks to the wonders of modern technology you can ALWAYS reach me, if only to leave a message.

Schedule of Readings and Class Activities

Week One
       
August 27: Introduction to goals, themes, and procedures
     
*** Sunday, August 29: Required attendance at showing of film, "Black Robe" in ARH 302 at 7:00 p.m. Students from both sections of History 195 will view this film together.
       
Week Two
       
August 30: Discuss "Black Robe" in light of the assumptions and expectations we bring to the study of "cultural encounters"
  Reading: You should begin your reading on the Spanish-Mexican encounter over the weekend. This is your opportunity to avoid falling behind.
       
September 1: The Cultural Creation of Political Mythologies: Aztecs, Incas, and Iberians
  Reading: PACKET - Stannard, American Holocaust; Burkholder & Johnson, pp. 13-41; Laws of Burgos, pp. 11-19 only
       
September 3: The Spanish View of the Encounter with Mexico
  Reading: PACKET - del Castillo excerpts, pp. 3-254; Burkholder & Johnson, pp. 46-50
  Writing assignment: See Study Guide for issues to address in brief commentary due
in class.
       
Week Three    
       
September 6: The Mexican View of the Encounter with Spain
  Reading: Broken Spears. See Study Guide to identify the most important sections of this book.
       
  September 8: The Cultural Encounter over Religion: Mexicans and Catholics
  Reading: PACKET - de Las Casas, In Defense of the Indians, pp. 3-53 and 221-239
     
September 10: The Religious Encounter continued
  Reading: PACKET - Mills & Taylor, 19-22; Motolinia, pp. 51-57, 131-133; Duran/Book of the Gods, pp. 51-56, 383-387; Duran/History of the Indies, pp. 3-11; Laws of Burgos, pp. 11-35.
  Writing assignment: One-page comparison of the Catholic attitudes toward Indian religion in Laws of Burgos, de Las Casas, and Duran.
       
Week Four    
       
September 13: How to Tell the Story?
  Reading: PACKET - Stanndard (review) and Stern, "Paradigms of Conquest"
  Writing assignment: One paragraph statement of Stern's "thesis."
       
September 15: Reflections on Cultural Encounters and on Storytelling
Reading: Hand-outs by Limerick and Somekawa/Smith
       
September 17: No class.
  Reading: Start reading Thornton, Africa and Africans for Monday.
  ***The 90-minute film "Africans in American, Part I: 1450-1750, "The Terrible
Transformation" is on Reserve in Burling Library Listening Room. I strongly
recommend this film to you to provide you with a base for reading Thornton.
       
Week Five
       
September 20: Africa and Africans: Encountering Thornton
  Reading: Thornton, Africa and Africans, Introduction and Chapters 1-4
  Writing assignment: Consult Study Guide for the chapter on which you are to
write a one-paragraph thesis statement.
  Note: Students who observe Yom Kippur should organize to meet with me on Tuesday, as a group, to discuss this reading and their thesis statements.
       
September 22: Cultural Encounters in Business and Government
  Reading: PACKET - Donnan/Slave Trade documents: pp. 19, 20, 22-26, 27-30, 47-50, 53-54, 57, 63-65, 68-70
  Writing assignment: One paragraph on how one of these documents either supports
Thornton's argument or raises questions about that argument.
       
September 24: Enslaved Africans Encounter the "Culture" of the Atlantic Slave Trade
  Reading: Thornton, Chapter 11; PACKET - Donnan documents: pp. 1-9; 21, 33-34; pp. 41-47; pp. 55-56; HAND-OUT re: Olaudah Equiano
  Writing assignment: One paragraph on how one of these documents either supports
Thornton's argument or raises questions about that argument.
       
Week Six    
       
September 27: Africans in the New World: the Cultural Exchange
  Reading: Thornton, Chaps. 5-8
  Writing assignment: Consult Study Guide for the chapter on which you are
write a one-paragraph thesis statement.
       
September 29: Religious Syncretism in the New World
  Reading: Thornton, Chapter 9; PACKET - Genovese, Stuckey
       
October 1: In-class essay exam on African Slave Trade
       
Week Seven    
       
October 4: Jewish Diaspora: Cultural Encounter in Europe
  Reading: PACKET - Green in European Migrants; Mendes-Flohr, pp. 701-721, 372-380;
Dawidowicz, The Golden Tradition: "Memoirs of a Grandmother"
       
October 6: The Debate over Jewish Identity and Assimilation
  Reading: PACKET - Mendes-Flohr, pp. 400-406; Chazam & Raphael, pp. 15-31. Arnold White, "The Jewish Question," and additional documents will be distributed in class.
       
October 8: Jews and Nationhood
  Reading: PACKET - Mendes-Flohr, pp. 337-350; Renan, "What is a Nation?" pp. 61-83
  Writing assignment: One-paragraph statement of Renan's thesis.
       
Week Eight    
       
October 11: The Dreyfus Affair: Attitudes Underlying the "Encounter"
  Reading: Burns, France and the Dreyfus Affair, pp. vii-90
       
October 13: The Culture Wars and the French
  Reading: Burns, France and the Dreyfus Affair, pp. 90-172; review Renan
  Library assignment: Find one article from listing in Guide to Periodical Literature
hand-out. Bring to class.
       
October 15: Zionism: a Cultural Dis-encounter?
  Reading: Burns, France and the Dreyfus Affair, pp. 173-192; Hertzberg, 469-476/Lazare; Mendes-Flohr, pp. 529-571 (excerpts).
       
Week Nine — Fall Break
       
Week Ten
       
October 25: Chinese in Thailand: Migrants' Choices and Constraints
  Reading: PACKET - Spence, pp. 1-27/Maps, pp. 210-215; Skinner, pp. 28-67
       
October 27: Chinese in Thailand: Sanguine Encounter?
  Reading: PACKET - Skinner, pp. 91-125
       
October 29: Chinese in Thailand: Costs and Benefits of Assimilation
  Reading: PACKET - Skinner, pp. 126-154
       
Week Eleven  
       
November 1: Chinese in America: Migrants' Choices and Constraints
  Reading: PACKET - Congressional Record; articles from Harper's Weekly on "The Geary Law," Ronald Takaki, pp. 21-42, 79-131
  Film: "Ancestors in America, Part II" will be shown at noon on Friday, October 29 in our classroom. It will also be on Reserve in the A-V Center over the weekend. It is 60 minutes long and should be viewed by Monday's class meeting.
       
November 3: Chinese Prostitutes and Protestant Missionary Women: A Gendered Encounter
  Reading: PACKET - Yung, Unbound Feet, pp. 1-4, 15-51; "Wong Ah So, Filial Daughter;" "Rescued Chinese Prostitutes;" Cameron, "New Lives for Old"
  Writing assignment: Half-page interpretation of the relationship between Chinese
and Protestant missionary women.
       
November 5:  Victims or Agents? Chinese and Protestant Women Encounter One Another
  Reading: PACKET - Pascoe, "Gender Systems in Conflict"
  Writing assignment: One-paragraph statement of Pascoe's thesis.
       
Week Twelve    
       
  November 8: Transplanting Poland to Chicago
  Reading: PACKET - Pacyga, pp. 1-81
  Writing assignment: Based on first 80 pages, identify Pacyga's thesis
       
  ***Note that I need to schedule a special EVENING meeting on this day.
We will not meet at 9:00 a.m. Class will decide what hour in p.m. is best.
       
November 10: Cultural Encounters in "The Jungle"
  Reading: PACKET - Pacyga, pp. 111-157; Sinclair, The Jungle, pp. 1-19, 207-225; Barrett, "Life in ‘The Jungle';" Kaztauskis, "From Lithuania to the Chicago Stockyards"
       
November 12: Labor Encounters Capital in Stockyards, 1904
  Reading: PACKET - Pacyga, pp. 158-205; Poole; McDowell; Stewart
       
  Topics for 5-page research paper due on November 24 will be distributed in class.
       
Week Thirteen
       
November 15: Encounter of Eastern Europeans & African-Americans in "The Jungle"
  Reading: PACKET - Pacyga, pp. 206-227, 238-257; Spear, pp. 147-166
       
November 17: Different Meanings of "Union" in 1919
  Reading: PACKET - Grossman, pp. 208-245 (and Endnotes, 337-347); Crisis; McDowell
       
November 19: Different Meanings of "Americanization" in 1919
  Reading: PACKET - Barrett, "Americanization from the Bottom Up"
       
Week Fourteen  
       
November 22: Small group meetings to discuss research.
       
November 24: Discuss findings from research papers.
       
November 26: THANKSGIVING VACATION
       
Week Fifteen  
       
November 29: Apartheid: Theory and Practice
  Reading: PACKET - Sparks, pp. 147-182, 195-229
       
December 1: Cultural Encounters Under Apartheid: Children's Views
  Reading: PACKET - Courtenay, The Power of One, pp. 19-51
Mathanbe, Kaffir Boy, pp. ix-62
       
December 3: Cultural Encounters Under Apartheid: Children's Views continued
  Reading: Mathanabe, pp. 86-103, 123-134, 170-204
  Writing assignment: One-page consideration of the arguments for and against using
autobiography as a historical source.
       
Week Sixteen  
       
December 6: Cultural Encounters Under Apartheid: Can the gap be bridged?
  Reading: Malan, My Traitor's Heart, pp. 13-103, 181-235
       
December 8: Cultural Encounters Under Apartheid: The Failure of Good Will?
  Reading: Malan, My Traitor's Heart, pp. 339-425
       
December 10: Cultural Encounters in the NEW South Africa
  Reading: PACKET - Preamble and Bill of Rights to South African Constitution
       
  Final essay questions will be distributed in class.
       

Final Exam Period: Friday, December 17 at 9:00 a.m.
Essays will be due at that time.
We will meet to review and evaluate the course.