Anthropology 295.01 "Special Topic: Anthropology & Representations of
Mixed-Race."
MW 8-9:50 FA - 242
Prof. Katya Gibel Azoulay,
ARH 121 (tel 4324)
Office Hours: Mon &
Wed
This course examines
anthropology's contribution to the taxonomy and representations of “race” and
“culture” and its role in prescribing and proscribing the idea of interracial
intimacy. Over the course of the semester, we will examine how the topic of
mixing and miscegenation was invented, elaborated and obsessed over by
anthropologists, philosophers, judges, policy-makers, film directors and people
raced as "mixed."
BACKGROUND READING
ASSIGNMENT
i
What
everyone should know about race: the following readings are in blue because they should be almost
memorized before Mon 30 August. They are accessible at Background Readings on
the website for Race: Power of an Illusion at pbs.org – http://www.pbs.org/race/000_General/000_00-Home.htm
•
Science Background
•
Richard
S. Garcia “The Misuse of Race in Medical Diagnosis.”
•
Jared Diamond “Races Without Colors.”
•
Troy Duster, “Op Ed”
History
Background
•
George Fredrickson, “The Historical
Origins and Development of Racism.”
• Barbara J. Fields, “edited transcript”
READING
ASSIGNMENTS
The
first half of the semester will be focused on a close reading of Robert Young, Colonial
Desire: Hybridity in Theory, Culture and Race (Routledge 1995) which
historicizes and analyzes the notion of difference. The discourse on race
as a theory of science and a political ideology emerged on both sides of the
In the
second half of the semester, we will use Kevin R. Johnson, Mixed Race
America and the Law (NYU Press, 2004) a compilation of abridged articles on
“mixed race.”I will identify additional supplementary reading assignments which
contribute to interrogating and theorizing the construction of race and its
corollary, mixed-race in greater detail. During this period, we will view
several films and documentaries and consider the ways in which the discourse of
multiracialism and new representations of race undermine or
reinforce racism. NOTE: Several films will be
shown at 10:30 on Saturday mornings – if you are unable to attend a screening,
you are responsible for viewing the film on your own before Monday’s class
meeting. (Films will be on reserve in Burling -- however, I will check them out
for 24 hours on Friday afternoons).
WRITING
ASSIGNMENTS
T Weekly Journal: (30%)
The
first half of the semester you will acquiring new
information and a historical context for understanding how desire/disgust
shaped a trans-Atlantic white Christian European academic inquiry, policies and
public attitudes towards notions of purity and mixing. Robert Young (Colonial
Desire) offers an analysis that subjects anthropological ideas about culture
to careful scrutiny and calls into question contemporary theories of
post-colonialism and ethnicity.
Every student must keep a reading
journal which outlines the main points of each chapter and highlights important
footnote. Each entry represents a conversation with the text, the author and
class discussions:
What did you learn? What were the main points? What is the significance
of the chapter? How does it build on the previous chapter? What new information
or questions are raised which offer you ideas that can
be applied to other courses you have or are currently taking?
Each of the 12 Parts of Kevin Johnson, Mixed Race America and the Law are followed by a set of review questions. You are responsible for reviewing the questions for the assigned reading before class discussion and then addressing them in writing after class discussion as part of the journal entry assignments. Reflections from supplementary readings and handouts, including material that you find independently and feel is of relevance, should be incorporated into these entries or may be entered into your journal as a separate entry.
ü Reflection papers on Films (20%):
Many of the films we will see do not
directly compliment the readings – instead, they register various popular and
unpopular perspectives intended to influence the viewing audience. You will
keep a separate set of entries on the films (commercial, independent, made for
TV and documentaries). Your 2-3 page film reflections should draw on insights
you gained cumulatively from the readings – they should not model a film
critic’s review. Instead, your focus should be on the messages, images,
stereotypes, etc which are projected to an audience:
Who does the target audience appear to be? What information is
conveyed? How are traditional notions of purity and mixing
reenforced or undermined in each film? Whose political concerns are addressed?
Is the focus on individual identity or national identity? How are individual
agency and institutional structures balanced in the films?
The journals are to be dated, typed, and paginated. Your
ideas will not be graded as "correct" or "incorrect"
-- rather this is an opportunity to review, explore, and engage with ideas,
historical information, theoretical approaches, and new articulations.
Format for typing your entries:
•
Left Margin
1.5", Right Margin 1."
•
Double spaced and
standard font.
•
Pages must
be numbered sequentially.
•
Entries must
be dated (the dates are for you to review the development of your thoughts at
the end of the semester.)
The
journal entries count toward your final grade but will not receive individual
grades. Journal entries are due on Fridays by
T Final Paper (30%)
The
culminating project for this course will be a 8-10
page essay, informed by the readings, which addresses Robert Young’s concluding
question: why do our own forms of racism remain so
intimately bound up with sexuality and desire? Considering the
context of the U.S. American black/white binary as a point of departure, in
what ways do racial identities conform, compromise and confound contemporary
ideas about racial difference? What are the political implications for
celebrating racial diversity and racial mixing in terms of power
and distribution of resources? What role do questions of racism, as a
political phenomenon, occupy in the discourse on “mixed race” people?
This paper should have a title page
and a bibliography which draws extensively from the bibliographical references
in the texts of the semester.
CLASS
DISCUSSION & PRESENTATION
T
Leading
Discussions (15%)
For each class, three students will
be responsible for writing and distributing an outline of key
points for class distribution. This group will also discuss the main
argument(s) of an essay (or chapter): how and why the reading is
significant to the key themes or topics under discussion? How are issues linked
to previous readings and class discussions? The group will highlight specific
passages and comment on them as well as raise questions for discussion – the
group is responsible for addressing these questions in their presentation and
then opening them up for class discussion. Each presentation should
take about 20 minutes.
T
Class
Discussions (5%):
It is appropriate for there to be
differences in opinion. This furthers our own understanding of the topic. This
class provides the opportunity to engage with a perspective which is in
opposition to your own. NOTE: Consensus is not the purpose of class
discussion! Each of you is responsible for overcoming the urge to be silent
rather than to disagree, or to be constrained by the silencing effect of
obsessive politeness. Your efforts should be directed toward developing an
informed perspective which serves as a basis for analysis and articulation.
Active engagement through discussion helps to sharpen how you articulate
your ideas – therefore, being challenged through discussion helps you refine
the ways in which you articulate these ideas.
Critical thinking and exchanging
ideas depends on listening carefully to another person's perspective and responding
respectfully and effectively. The focus should be specifically on what
and why there are points of agreement or disagreement -- how is one
interpretation different and in what ways should it be valued as more or less
persuasive? Personal experience is important, but you may draw on it as
an additional resource -- not a substitute -- for information or
evidence from the texts we will be reading. In other words, your arguments always
need to be situated within the context of the common readings although they may
also be supplemented with outside sources.
You should therefore always back up your comments with reference to
the texts and specific passages and page numbers (hence the notes you bring
to class are important)!
You must keep a hard-back folder
with three sections for each of your written material (journal entries; film
evaluations; final paper) which will be submitted at the end of the semester in
a stamped, self-addressed envelope.
Do not reprint. If you will be back on campus in Spring
semester, you may use your campus mailbox as the returning address.
ALL WRITTEN WORK AND FINAL PAPER ARE DUE NO LATER THAN
Weekly Schedule
Week 1
SAT 28 Aug 10 AM PART 1: AFRICANS IN
Syllabi will be distributed – first
reading assignments are required for Mon 30 Aug
Mon 30 August
Introductions
Kevin
Johnson Part I – A “The History of Anti-Miscegenation Laws”
(JSTOR)
Sidney Kaplan, “The Miscegenation Issue in the Election of 1864" Journal
of Negro History 34, 3 pp. 274-343.
Wed 1 Sept
Discussion:
KJ Part I - B “The Road to Loving v
In
class: discussion of Review Questions (be prepared: you should have
notes and cited passages to highlight in your discussion of the review
questions)
Week 2
SAT 4 SEPT
R. Young Colonial Desire:
Hybridity & Diaspora
Mon 6
Sept pp. xi-22
Wed 8
Sept pp. 22-28
Week 3
R. Young Colonial Desire:
Culture & the History of Difference
Mon 13
Sept pp. 29-43
Discussants:
Wed 15
Sept pp. 43-54
Discussants:
Week 4
R. Young Colonial Desire: The
Complicity of Culture
Mon 20
Sept pp. 55-72
Discussants:
Wed 22
Sept pp. 72-89
Discussants:
Week 5
R. Young Colonial Desire: Sex
and Inequality
Mon 27 Sept pp.
90-109
Discussants:
Wed 29 Sept pp. 109-117
Discussants
Week 6
R. Young Colonial Desire:
Mon 4 Oct pp. 118-133
Discussants:
Wed 6 Oct pp. 133-141
Discussants:
Week 7
R. Young Colonial Desire
** Mon
11 Oct
White Power, White Desire pp. 142-158 and Colonialism and the Desiring Machine
159-182
**
Wed 13 Oct NO CLASS
Last journal entry (5-6 pp) on Colonial
Desire should include discussion of the two final chapters as well as a
summary of what you learned from the book as a whole, in what ways it
intersects with other courses you are taking this semester (in theme and in
era) and preliminary thoughts about Robert Young’s concluding question: why do our own forms of racism remain so intimately bound up
with sexuality and desire?
....................fall
break....................
Week 8
Mon 25 Oct
EBSCO: Gordon, Lewis R.
(1995) “Critical Mixed Race.” Social Identities 1, 2
EBSCO: Udry, J. Richard
et.al (2003). “Health and Behavior Risks of Adolescents with
Mixed-Race Identity.” American Journal of Public Health 93,1.
JSTOR: Foeman &
Nance (1999) “From Miscegenation to Multiculturalism: Perception and Stages of
Interracial Relationship Development.” Journal of Black Studies 29,4.
In Class: Ethnic man! [videorecording] / Entertaining Diversity presents ;
written, produced and directed by Teja Arboleda, Barbara Wilson Arboleda Imprint Evanston, IL : Distributed by
AGC/United Learning, c2000 (35 min)
Wed 27
Oct K. Johnson; Part II: Racial
Identity
Discussants:
Week 9
SAT 30 OCT
Look up Hayes Code 1930 for specific restrictions on miscegenation [Hayes Office Production Code]: why didn’t the leading role of Pinky go to a black actress?
Find on Lexis Nexis (news) obituary by Bob Thomas, “Oscar-nominated actress Jeanne Crain dies at 78"
SUN 31 OCT
Screenplay by Richard Murphy and Philip
Yordan; produced by Sol C. Siegel; directed by Edward Dmytryk
Look up Katy Jurado: (she was most famous in the
Mon 1
Nov K. Johnson;
Part III: ‘Passing’
Discussants:
Wed 3 Nov
K. Johnson; Part IV: The Census
Supplementary
http://www.census.gov/population/www/socdemo/race/Ombdir15.html
T Bring to class the exact passage(s) quoting Office of Management & Budget (OMB) explanation for the use of racial categories on the U.S. Census.
T http://www.pbs.org/mattersofrace/prog4.shtml Matters of Race: Part 4 Tomorrow’s America
Discussants:
Week 10
SAT 6 NOV 10:30 AM Film:
A House Divided (TV 2000)
Mon 8 Nov K. Johnson; Part V: Inheritance
Rights
Read
on Lexis Nexis the case of Amanda America Dickson (1887)–Go to “Get a Case”: Smith
v. Du Bose, 78
Read e-reserve reading by Josephine Boyd Bradley and Kent Anderson Lelise “White Pain Pollen: An Elite Biracial Daugher’s Quandry.”
Discussants:
Wed 10
Nov K. Johnson; Part VI: Discrimination
and “Colorism”
Banana split [videorecording] : 25 stories / by Kip Fulbeck
Imprint
Week 11
Mon 15
Nov K. Johnson; Part VII:
Affirmative Action
Discussants:
Wed
17
Continuation of discussion....
Week 12
Mon 22
Nov K. Johnson; Part IX: The
Immigration and Naturalization Laws
Discussants:
Wed 24
Nov K. Johnson; Part X: Racial
Mixture Outside the
What
my mother told me [videorecording] / a film by Frances-Anne Solomon
Imprint
The
Body beautiful [videorecording] / a film by Ngozi Onwurah
Imprint
Discussants:
Week 13
Mon 29
Nov
(JSTOR)
Joachim Warmbold (1992), “If Only She Didn’t Have Negro Blood in Her Veins: The
Concept of Metissage in German Colonial Literature.” Journal of Black
Studies 23, 2
(EBSCO)
Ramsay, Guy (2001). “Myth, Moment and the Challenge of Identities: stories from
Australians of Indigenous and Chinese ancestry.
Discussants:
Wed 1 Dec
K. Johnson
Part
XI: A Mixed Race Society: The End of Racism?
Part
XII: Future Mixed Race Legal Studies
Doubles
[videorecording] :
Imprint [
Week 14
Mon
6 Dec – Documentaries
Just black? [videorecording] / produced by Francine Winddance
Twine, Jonathan Frederick Warren, Francisco Ferrandiz Martin (59 min)
Imprint
Interracial
marriage [videorecording] : blending the races in
Wed
8 Dec Documentaries
Beyond
black and white [videorecording] / Mian Productions ; produced,
directed by Nisma Zaman Imprint New
York, N.Y. : Women Make Movies [distributor], c1995 (26 min)
Domino
[videorecording] : interracial people and the search
for identity / a
production of the National Film Board of Canada in association with Lucinda
Films, Inc
Imprint
Exam Week –
Final paper due
Final
paper: 8-10 page essay,
cumulatively informed by the semester’s readings.
Address Robert Young’s concluding
question: why do our own forms of racism remain so
intimately bound up with sexuality and desire?
< Considering the context of the U.S. American black/white binary as a point of departure, in what ways do racial identities conform, compromise and confound contemporary ideas about racial difference?
< What are the political implications for celebrating racial diversity and racial mixing in terms of power and distribution of resources?
< What role do questions of racism, as a political phenomenon, occupy in the discourse on “mixed race” people?
< This paper should have a title page and a bibliography which draws extensively from the bibliographical references in the texts (print and visual) from the semester.